ZRP
Tuca Zbarcea & Asociatii

Țuca Zbârcea & Asociații obtains a landmark ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union, which renders ineffective the entire Emergency Ordinance No. 25 ̸ 2021 on the exclusion of non-EU economic operators from public procurement procedures

14 Martie 2025   |   BizLawyer

Țuca Zbârcea & Asociații challenged the legal grounds for the exclusion of the consortium and obtained, in the spring of 2022, the referral to the Court of Justice of the European Union with a series of questions regarding the compliance of the new exclusion rule introduced by the Romanian State with EU law.

 
 
Țuca Zbârcea & Asociații has obtained a ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), confirming that national legislation excluding non-EU economic operators from public procurement procedures has no legal effect. 

In a high-stakes public procurement procedure worth approximately EUR 750 million, Țuca Zbârcea & Asociații represented a joint venture between a Romanian company and a non-EU one, which was excluded following the Romanian Government’s adoption of Emergency Ordinance No. 25/2021. This legislative act imposed the sanction of exclusion for all economic operators from non-EU countries that had not signed a free-market access agreement with the European Union.


Țuca Zbârcea & Asociații challenged the legal grounds for the exclusion of the consortium and obtained, in the spring of 2022, the referral to the Court of Justice of the European Union with a series of questions regarding the compliance of the new exclusion rule introduced by the Romanian State with EU law.

Almost three years after the referral, the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled, in its judgment of 13 March 2025 in Case C-266/22, that primary EU law precludes a Member State from adopting national legislation excluding an economic operator from a third-country which has not concluded a free-market access agreement with the EU, as such a measure falls within the exclusive competence of the European Union. Accordingly, "the national legislation at issue in the main proceedings requiring the contracting authority to exclude those economic operators cannot be applied." (paragraph 64 of the Judgment).

Consequently, the judgment expressly disapplies a legislative act of the Romanian State, i.e. Emergency Ordinance No. 25/2021, based on the principle of the primacy of EU law in relation to its exclusive competence in the area of the common commercial policy, pursuant to Article 3(1)(e) of the TFEU. The principle of this judgment becomes applicable whenever a Member State has adopted or adopts a national exclusion legislation, since “there was no provision of EU law which required the admission to or the exclusion […] of economic operators of a third country” (paragraph 64 of the Judgment).

Throughout the legal dispute before the national courts and the proceedings before the CJEU, the claimant consortium was represented by Dan Cristea, Partner at Țuca Zbârcea & Asociații, with support from Șerban Sârbu, Senior Associate.

"The implications of this ECJ decision are far-reaching and impossible to summarize in a few sentences, since an interpretative ruling in a preliminary reference case does not apply only to the specific dispute in question, but extends to all similar legal relationships where an economic operator would have been excluded under a national law. It is also important that the Judgment is clear-cut and leaves no room for interpretation regarding the inapplicability of the national law that led to our client’s exclusion from such a high-value procedure. Beyond its impact on specific cases, some of huge value, not only in Romania, and beyond the importance of the clarifications it brings to the European Union's commercial relations with non-EU countries, I take pride in the fact that this ruling reflects a fundamental principle of our legal team: the ability to find creative solutions to complex cases, to think outside conventional frameworks—even when facing one of the most formidable legal obstacles a state authority can impose: national law. Ultimately, I take great satisfaction when a client places its trust in our ability to innovate”, declared Dan Cristea.

Țuca Zbârcea & Asociaţii has a leading practice in Dispute Resolution, the firm’s pre-eminence in this area being already acknowledged by renowned international publications, such as Chambers & Partners, Legal 500 and the Global Arbitration Review.
 
 

PNSA

 
 

ARTICOLE PE ACEEASI TEMA

ARTICOLE DE ACELASI AUTOR


 

Ascunde Reclama
 
 

POSTEAZA UN COMENTARIU


Nume *
Email (nu va fi publicat) *
Comentariu *
Cod de securitate*







* campuri obligatorii


Articol 28 / 4475
 

Ascunde Reclama
 
BREAKING NEWS
ESENTIAL
NNDKP a asistat MedLife cu privire la majorarea limitei unui credit sindicalizat cu 50 milioane EUR. Ce avocați au fost în echipa de proiect
INTERVIURI ESENȚIALE | Dr. Cosmin Vasile, Managing Partner - ZRVP: Într-o piață a avocaturii marcată de numeroase spin-off-uri, ZRVP se remarcă drept singura firmă de avocatură de anvergură care a luat naștere printr-o fuziune și s-a consolidat printr-o a doua fuziune. Concentrarea pe avocatură și nu pe business-ul pe care îl reprezintă avocatura a asigurat stabilitatea avocaților-cheie și a portofoliului de clienți
LegiTeam: Atorney at Law | Dispute Resolution for commercial ̸ administrative litigation and arbitration | Reff & Associates
Schoenherr a asistat Verbund cu privire la achiziția unui proiect eolian de 272 MW de la Monsson. Echipa a fost coordonată de Monica Cojocaru (partner)
BACIU PARTNERS câștigă premiul ‘Firma de Copyright & Design a Anului în România’ la gala Managing IP EMEA Awards 2025, desfășurată la Londra. Andreea Bende (Partener), premiată ca ‘Practicianul Anului în România’ | Ana-Maria Baciu, Managing Partner: ”Este o reconfirmare a faptului că principiile pe care le integrăm în fiecare proiect creează în mod constant valoare tangibilă, vizibilă și demnă de recunoaștere”
CMS România își mărește echipa în România prin cooptarea strategică a unui senior counsel și lansează practica de Apărare | Horea Popescu (Managing Partner): „Cristian Băcanu se remarcă printr-o combinație unică de experiență juridică, leadership în sectorul public și viziune internațională, ceea ce îl recomandă ca un membru valoros al echipei noastre”
LegiTeam: POPESCU & ASOCIAȚII recrutează avocați stagiari (București)
Cei mai buni litigatori din România, văzuți de Chambers Europe 2025 | Cine sunt practicienii apreciați de clienți în practica de Dispute Resolution și ce spun clienții despre aceștia. Nouă avocați români sunt evidențiați în practica de arbitraj
LegiTeam: Zamfirescu Racoţi Vasile & Partners recrutează avocat definitiv dreptul muncii | Consultanță
Trei avocați români de la Bondoc & Asociații, Filip & Company și DLA Piper sunt considerați ‘Eminent Practitioners’ în practica de fuziuni și achiziții. Clasamentul Chambers Europe 2025, cu cei mai buni avocați de Corporate ̸ M&A din România
Filip & Company a asistat Victoriabank în achiziția OCN “Microinvest” SRL în Republica Moldova. Alina Stancu Bîrsan (partener) a coordonat echipa de proiect
LegiTeam: Lawyer in Real Estate | Reff & Associates
 
Citeste pe SeeNews Digital Network
  • BizBanker

  • BizLeader

      in curand...
  • SeeNews

    in curand...